With early voting underway, questions about ICE at polls are surfacing as voters consider what immigration enforcement might look like at voting sites through Election Day.
Homeland Security officials say they do not intend to deploy immigration officers to monitor voting locations and have dismissed broad deployment concerns as fearmongering. Election law specialists note federal law bars sending armed troops or agents to election sites except to repel armed enemies of the United States, a rare circumstance.
Still, groups representing Latino, Black and Asian American voters point to heated rhetoric and ongoing immigration operations as reasons for concern at a time when immigration arrests are rising under President Donald Trump’s deportation agenda.
What DHS and agency leaders say about ICE at polls
In congressional testimony earlier this year, the then-acting head of Immigration and Customs Enforcement, Todd Lyons, and Customs and Border Protection chief Rodney Scott said they had no plans to send officers to the polls. Lyons has since left the post. A Homeland Security official also told state election administrators that agents will not be stationed at voting locations for the midterms.
In September, DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin said Democrats were fearmongering by raising the issue. He said officers would not broadly patrol or monitor polling places, though he left open specific scenarios such as executing a warrant or responding to a threat.
Attorney General Todd Blanche, then serving as deputy attorney general, also commented earlier this year, asking why there were objections to sending ICE officers to polling places and saying noncitizens cannot vote.
Trump has repeatedly raised the possibility of illegal noncitizen voting, even as research and investigations have found it to be extremely rare. He has not said he would order ICE to polling places, nor has he ruled it out. Asked in May if he would send the National Guard or ICE to voting sites in November, he said he would do what is necessary to ensure honest elections. In a Time magazine interview published Thursday, he said he had not thought about sending ICE agents to polling locations.
In a statement, Homeland Security said people in the country legally have nothing to fear and that ICE is not planning operations targeting polling places. The agency said it conducts intelligence-driven targeted enforcement and could act if a public safety threat endangers a voting site. The department also said it is focused on prosecuting and removing noncitizens who vote and preventing dilution of U.S. citizens’ ballots.
Legal limits on armed presence at voting sites
A Civil War-era federal statute prohibits deploying troops or armed men to places where elections are held unless needed to repel armed enemies of the United States. David Becker, a former Justice Department attorney who leads the nonprofit Center for Election Innovation & Research, said any armed individual at a polling place would trigger swift court action and that jurisdictions are preparing for that possibility.
Jonathan Diaz, director of voting advocacy and partnerships at the nonprofit Campaign Legal Center, said the law applies to any location where voting occurs, including polling places, early voting centers, ballot drop boxes and election offices. He said even narrow exceptions, such as pursuing an individual warrant at a polling site, are legally questionable because the statute does not carve out routine law enforcement. He added that an armed presence near, but not at, the polls could also raise legal issues, and other federal and state voter intimidation laws could apply.
Election officials and advocates prepare for uncertainties
Local election officials discussed the possibility of federal agents at voting sites during a meeting in Washington and said preparations are in place. Dean Logan, who oversees Los Angeles County’s elections, said observers are welcome but distractions for voters are not, adding that his team will ensure voters can cast ballots without disruption.
Critics of the administration cite Trump’s remarks that Republicans should take over voting in at least 15 places, as well as support from allies like podcaster Steve Bannon for an ICE presence at polls. Dan Freeman, litigation director for the Democratic National Committee, said the chance of immigration agents at voting locations is low, but his team is ready to go to court if needed because neither Trump nor Secretary Mullin has ruled it out.
Civil rights groups that have filed lawsuits to block any ICE presence at voting sites say administration rhetoric, along with months of immigration enforcement activity, has left Latino, Asian American, Black and other voters uneasy. Advocates say many Latino citizens already limit daily activities over fears of ICE, and that rumors of activity at a single polling place could discourage voters elsewhere.
Juan Proaño of the League of United Latin American Citizens said ICE would not need to appear at many sites to have an effect because social media can quickly amplify isolated incidents. He said even the presence of agents in or around polling locations can deter voters, and current threats are influencing decisions people will make on Election Day.
Advocates also point to a summer incident in Syracuse, New York, where Homeland Security Investigations agents, a unit within ICE that has taken a lead on voter fraud probes, went to a polling place to serve written notice to a woman accused of posting federal officers’ personal information.
Despite concerns, advocacy groups are urging turnout, educating voters about their rights and expanding legal assistance. Thu Nguyen of OCA-Asian Pacific American Advocates said the organization is recruiting election observers in response to community fears. Nguyen said some U.S. citizens worry because ICE has previously detained Americans or because they have relatives without immigration status and fear drawing attention to them.
A nonpartisan coalition of Trump administration opponents is launching a VoteSafe program in Georgia, Michigan, North Carolina and Ohio to build confidence that voters can safely cast ballots. Mary Corcoran, executive director of the Save America Movement, said the effort will rely on trusted community leaders to address anxiety about armed agents at the polls. “Our job is to overcome it,” she said.
Hawaiʻi voters can find information on local voting procedures and rights through the state Office of Elections and county clerks. Officials advise reporting any intimidation or disruptions to election workers or law enforcement.
Related coverage: Fairfax County ICE detainer not honored in child sex case.
One Response